Thursday, September 29, 2005

Digital Photo Guide - Part 3 - The Procedures

Now we finally get down the the way to do it all right. Consider steps 1 through 6 to be your procedure for handling your digital photos to keep them safe and viable for generations.

0. Selecting a camera.
1. Resolution \ Format
2. Handling
3. Organizing
4. Modifying
5. Sharing
6. Archiving


CAMERA - Consider waiting for the technology to catch up with your budget, and not the other way around. There are a great many consumer sites where you can read about which are the best cameras to buy. I would start with cnet.com and epinions.com. Look for short reaction & refresh times, ignore digital zoom, look for the camera in the category you are looking with the biggest lens diameter. You do pay for what you get right now in digital. Consider connection options like cables or docks, the memory card type and amount, and the battery options.

RESOLUTION / FORMAT - Set your camera to record the highest resolution picture it can take, and use the least compression - or none if your camera can record RAW pictures. Adobe is now promoting a new file format DNG, or Digital Negative. If widely adopted, it promises to solve the format problems for raw camera data, but again, only if widely adopted, and that remains to be seen. In an event, save the raw data file if you can get hold of it. You can always convert to JPG or another popular format later - but maintaining that digital "negative" is critical. High compression adds artifacts to your photos - they may not be readily apparent, but may get worse as you enlarge, crop, modify, etc. If you don't like the fact that you can store fewer pictures - get more photo storage. Why would you want to lessen the quality of the camera you spent all that money on - you could have gotten a cheaper camera and spent the difference on memory cards.

HANDLING - After you take pictures, back up your digital photos immediately. Consider every place you store them a time bomb. If they are only on your camera you may be doomed. If they are on your camera and computer (hard drive), you are in slightly better shape, but not much. If they are on your computer and burned onto a CD in a case or storage sleeve (where they won't get scratched), you are in doing better. If you have a CD in a safe-deposit box with your last year's photos you are doing very good. Get yourself a CD holder so you can store all the CDs you burn of pictures immediately after you take them (think of them as "rolls"). Buy good quality CDs - archival quality if you can find them (there are very few companies) for the backups you do. Label the CDs with CD-safe markers (some markers can melt through CDs).

ORGANIZING - I can't recommend enough getting a good photo organizing program. There are many out there, but I am partial to iPhoto for the Mac. It is well integrated with iMovie and iPhoto and iTunes, so it makes working with different media a snap. It sorts all your photos in different manners, makes it easy to add Comments and other Metadata, and organizes the photos into different albums that I can choose, then can make slideshows, burn DVDs, publish them to websites, even order hardcover photo books. Bias aside, there are many fine programs out there in a range of prices - the Google software Picasa is even free. Do a little research to find one that works for you - here is a start... http://www.pcmag.com/category2/0,1874,1639144,00.asp

Spend the time to date the photos and enter the names of the people in the photos and the locations/events. You will appreciate it later when you are looking for the pictures.

Consider keeping your photos on an external hard drive just for photos. For a small investment you have a seperate drive that you use only for photos. If you have to reformat your main computer hard-drive (people often do), the photos are completely seperate. If there is a fire or flood you could just grab the external quickly and be on your way. You can use backup software to back up the entire drive and you will get all your pictures backed up. Lastly, you will know where to find them all.

MODIFYING - Many people modify their pictures changing the brightness, contrast, color, etc. and delete or change the original file. THIS IS A BIG NO-NO. Modifying the original file would be like pouring chemicals on your film negatives to lighten the images - you don't want to do anything destructive to your originals. Unless you are a digital photography expert, you probably don't know what you are doing - I know that is harsh, but it is true of even hardcore Technologists (like me). You can learn some new better way of modifying photos every day, so don't destroy the original. Make a copy if you are going to retouch. Go out to the web and learn about photo retouching - there are thousands of sites. The key software to have though is Adobe Photoshop or Photoshop Elements. This is the Microsoft Word of Photo Manipulation - there are other choices out there, but Photoshop is the gold standard. It is a powerful tool for retouching digital photographs that has almost no equal. Normally around $600, the "Light" version is Photoshop Elements is about $100, but contains most of the features an amateur photo retoucher would use. One rule though - you want to try to avoid retouching a photo that has been saved in a compressed format like JPG. Try using RAW or uncompressed TIFF images. This will reduce the chance that artifacts of compression become more visible as you manipulate the image.

PRINTS - Print your photos. Let me state that again. Print your photos. Printed photos are tangible - can be put in albums, will be appreciated more than a digital file that sits on your computer. You don't have to print every one - but print the majority of them, and the best method seems to having them done at a photo developer.

If you have invested $600 in an archival ink printer, by all means, print away, but it seems it is still cheaper to go to a developer to get lasting prints, whether you choose the one on the corner, or online developing if you can wait for the pics to be shipped to you (which may also be cheaper). Where you may find it cheaper to print at home might be large prints - 8x10 and such, but check how much your photo service charges - prices continue to fall.

As for where to go, it seems services with Fujicolor Crystal Archive paper will last the longest - up to 60 years. Kodak (Ektacolor Edge 8) paper is only rated to last 22 years. Paper is not the full story though. You want to have a digital "print" of your files - The Fuju Frontier system is an example, this printer uses lasers to "Photograph" your picture onto real photo paper.

Check if the prints are "coated", since some developers can deliver digital pictures with a coating that can resist against water, smudging & discoloration. Don't print at kiosks that print directly, as these are usually regular ink-jet printers, although kiosks that print to a photo printer "in the back" can be the same as if you dropped them off.

Different vendors can vary in quality, and you should experiment, and know that they may change their papers and methods at any time. Some that have been highly rated are Snapfish (Kodak paper), Shutterfly (Fuji paper) & Kodak Easyshare (Kodak paper). The most important thing is to ASK what you are getting wherever you go. Ask about longevity too - if your photo place does not seem knowledgable, go somewhere that is.

Once you settle on a vendor, and like their prints, you might think about conforming your monitor to that "developer". Hold up a sample photo you had printed to your monitor, and adjust the monitor colors and hue and brightness and contrast to closely match the printed output. This way, when you preview your images on your monitor, you can freely play with color and contrast, confident that the printed output will closely match what you see on the screen.

SHARING - Now the fun begins. Flickr & Shutterfly and Ofoto/Kodak EasyShare Gallery offer free unlimited photo storage. There are probably others too do a bit of research - try them all out if you want. SnapFish and Wal-Mart do accept TIFF files in addition to JPEG. Find out what archival benefits these services have - but be aware they may close down at any time, so do not rely on services like these to back-up your pics.

ARCHIVING - I know backups were mentioned in the Handling section above, but you need to do more to make sure those pictures last forever. Some organizing software like iPhoto have backup functions built in, so creating archives are easy. With the cost of blank CDs and DVDs so low, there is no reason not to make pleniful backups. Again, at the very minimum save ORIGINAL files to CDs or DVDs - modified files if you can. Consider that any place you save them may self destruct without forwarning, so redundancy is the key. Many professionals urge making 2 backups at the same time - it's not a bad thought, since copying a CD takes only a few minutes. My method would be to make a complete backup periodically - and to store that backup somewhere away from your originals. In a safe in the house might sound fine, but if you have a fire there goes both copies. A safe deposit box or a friend across town might be better choices - think about the flooding from Hurricane Katrina - the entire city underwater. Complete disaster. Would you want to be able to recover your memories from something like that - you can.

Give extra copies to family and friends. Upload your pictures to free online services too, like Flickr or Snapfish or Kodak. Not only will you have a free place to store them, but you can use the service to share them over the net and to order digital prints the cheapest way possible. Use archival quality CDs or DVDs if you can get them - they should easily last 10 years or more (ask your photo processor). Continue doing COMPLETE backups regularly. Even if you did them once a year (marry the task to a holiday like New Years, or Daylight Savings Time), since they are digital, the 10th year of backing up will have the same quality as the first year - but on fresh media that will take decades to decay - and as time advances better solutions may come along.

Consider the small time it takes to backup like paying for replacement insurance on all those valueable, irreplaceable photos. Well worth the investment.

Digital Photo Guide - Part 2 - The Promise

I don't want my previous detail of the problems of video detract you from going digital if you think it suits you. I just think unless you have a plan, it doesn't wind up being the great experience that everyone expects. Here I will go over the benefits that I see for digital photography to help you weigh your options and give you some ideas how to get the most out of digital.

1. Picture Guarantee
2. Potentially Cheap
3. Manipulation
4. Shareability
5. Archivability
6. Experimentation
7. Metadata
8. Display

Management, Post-Processing, Annotation, Meta-Data

GUARANTEED PICTURES - I think the #1 reason people go to digital is the immediate gratification. You take the picture and glance at the screen on the camera, and there is the results immediately. People crowd around the little screens looking at themselves just taken, and there is a novelty there that not everyone is used to yet. Sort of like the picture booths of the last century. There are some interesting film-digital hybrids though - cameras that take pictures in film, but capture a digital pic at the same time to see if you "got the shot" or not. It will be interesting to see if people demand more of this, but my feeling is not, even thought he potentially for the best of both worlds is there.

COST OF DIGITAL - The cost of digital photography has the potential to be cheaper than film, but printing at home is not the way to go. Photo printing services have been continually dropping in price at photo developers, running around $0.20 per print, and online services are even cheaper, around $0.15 per print. Since they buy in bulk, they can afford to print with sound inks, on good quality paper, with very expensive equipment that is out of the consumer's price range. Since digital photographs can be viewed before printing, the consumer can select what they want, and not print or even delete the photography misshaps - something almost everyone wishes for after they get their film back from the developer.

RETOUCHING & MANIPULATION - Practally everyone has heard of Adobe Photoshop. Why? Because doing things with photo retouching is cool! Even if you are not putting a Mohawk on your best friend, being able to improve the color and sharpness of photos, or crop and enlarge them to just how you want is amazingly powerful.

SHAREABILITY - Everyone loves to share photos, and digital makes it easy. Send a copy to a friend - they can print it themself or just check it out on the screen. Even better, you can send pictures from an entire event or years of events. Photo sites are popping up everywhere on the web. Flickr, Shutterfly and others allow you to post albums, have prints sent to you or your guests, and order all different sorts of customized products, from cups to calendars. You could give your entire family album to every member of your family - on a single CD. Which brings up archiving...

ARCHIVABILITY - Although Archiving digital is problematic in that there are no great long-term solutions, it's unique nature offers some benefits that traditional film does not. First, there is no decay of a digital image - only the medium which it is stored. Granted, if the hard drive with all your images crashes, who cares if the digital images would not decay - however, you can create another copy of a digital picture at the drop of a hat. If you back up your images and maintain a "fresh" backup. You could have a disc with every picture you own someplace "safe" and never have to worry about your photos being lost in a disaster.

EXPERIMENT - With digital photography, it costs practically nothing to experiment. I have had a camera for some time that is capable of more than I use it for. Since the cost of film and developing is prohibitive, I let the camera make the decisions for me, but if I could have the instant feedback on what playing with the exposure & f-stop might do, I would love to dabble in "real" photography. Afraid of nighttime photography? You don't have to be any more.

FLEXIBILITY - There are novel additions to digital cameras that are not relevant to film, like camera "docks". Kodak in particular sports camera docks to connect your camera to a TV or computer or printer. It makes the connection less bothersome than cables and such, but is again proprietary to each camera. Wi-fi is a growing trend, as are photo viewing devices like the iPod and others.

METADATA - You might be like "Whoa, Metadata - what the hell is that?" But it is more important than you know. Metadata is data about data - for instance - when you create a file on a computer the file type is metadata, the name of the file is metadata, the date the file was created or last changed is metadata.

Most cameras have the ability to embed metadata within the image, such as the time and date of the photograph, model of the camera, shutter speed, flash use, film speed etc, to aid in the reviewing and sorting of photographs. Newer cameras have amazing features like adding the GPS location and with extra software you can save info like who took the photo, who is in the photo, where it was, what the event was. Imagine being able to call up every picture of a particular person in your family at only birthday parties in Minnesota before 1989. Or simply every picture that your child is in. That is powerful. Metadata adds that flexibility.

DISPLAY - Digital opens up worlds of flexibility in terms of displaying photos and managing collections. Use them as screen savers and desktops - set up a digital photo frame that changes photos - put them online for friends to view in slideshows. Put them on a DVD and take them to a wedding or party. The possibilities are endless - but before you have a party with the pictures, you have to be prepared to have a workflow that keeps a lot of the problems with digital to a minimum. I'll cover how to bring it all together in the next section - The Procedures - http://trekbody.blogspot.com/2005/09/digital-photo-guide-part-3-procedures.html.

Digital Photo Guide - Part 1 - The Problems

Being the tech-saavy person that I am (i.e. Nerd), I often get asked about all things digital, and especially about digital cameras and photography. When I tell people that I have not gone digital yet, they are kind of surprised, and when they ask why, there are a number of reasons that come to mind.

1. Digital is still more expensive than film for the same quality.
2. Obsolesence
3. Digital Photography is not archival in nature.
4. It is too costly and time-consuming to print at home.
5. Pictures "disappear" when you don't print them.
6. Using film is simpler.

Those being stated, let me elaborate and define the problems you will have to address (as I will some day have to) when you go digital. It seems like a lot to think about, but this is important - these are your memories, they are the most personnally valuable things you may own. If I had to abandon my home, do you know what I would grab? The photographs - that's about it. Those are the things that are irreplacable, and I don't think anyone should jeopardize them.

THE LENS - No matter what type of camera you are using, one rule of thumb stands out - the larger the lens, the better the picture. If you have a large lens, you are capturing more light and therefore, start the entire photography process with the best foundation. I currently own a Canon EOS IX APS camera. APS or Advantix is a format that was introduced in the 90's to make film a bit easier to handle. I love the format with one exception - the reason in never grew REALLY popular was because they decided to use a smaller piece of film - only about 24mm. Professionals and semi-pros never moved to the format because of the inherant loss of quality. BUT, I can tell you that many of my photographs are highly impressive, due to the better lens. The lens will make up for many failings - so start with that in mind. If you a buying a little tiny digital, although convenient, it will have to be well-made to make the most of a tiny view of the world. This is not to say that there are not some very-high quality small lenses in cameras, and lesser quality larger lenses - but think of it in terms of a telescope - you can play with the images all you want - but a bigger opening captures more light. New technology may help this in smaller cameras, as you see things like deforming liquid lenses enter the market.

SENSOR QUALITY - A square of 35mm film has the equivalent resolution of approximately 6 megapixels at 200 ISO. At lower ISO's the quality of film is even greater - requiring up to 20 megapixels (at higher ISO's, many digitals can take the lead, adjusting for lower light levels). 6 Megapixel cameras are still in the hundreds of dollars, and falling, but even then, megapixels don't tell the whole story. Most digital cameras divide their Megapixels into the 3 colors, so on a 6-megapixel camera, 2 are seeing green, 2 blue, and 2 yellow, so they are effectively only 2-Mpixel cameras. So, a your average 3-megapixel camera is only effectively 1-MPixel, 1\6th of the detail possible with film. Then there is the very technical issue of the sensor. Without going into great detail here, there are different ways they capture, and different sizes. You could reference this very weighty article here (http://www.photo.net/equipment/digital/sensorsize/) or just understand that the larger the sensor size, the better, even for equivalent megapixels. Since most digitals use an extremely small sensor, the lenses must squeeze the image down to that size before it is captured by the camera. The more you have to squeeze, the more you need a high-quality lens to get a great picture. This is not going to happen on cheap camera, so with a more expensive digital (prosumer & professional level), you get both higher quality lenses & higher size/quality sensor. This is very different from a film camera, where you are really paying for difference in lens only.

PROCESSING - In film, you wouldn't have to worry about the camera "doing" anything with the information it has, but in digital, it matters. Since the camera is capturing light with an imperfect sensor, it must do some computations to bring the image to the highest quality it can. It must interpret colors captured in 3-different shades, bring them together as true-color, reducing flaws that come from using a digital sensor and even reduce noise and increase range of detail in low-light situations. There is no easy way to look at a camera or a box and figure these details out, so you have to turn to professional reviews in magazines or online to determine which cameras actually turn a scene into a great digital photo. Try to find articles with side-by-side photos showing the difference between 2 cameras. You can find sometimes significant differences with cameras of similar sensor size, megapixels and lens quality.

OTHER DIGITAL CAMERA SHORTCOMINGS - one of the most often-complained problems with digital cameras is shutter lag. Basically the time it takes after pressing the button to take the picture. Some delay up to two seconds. If you do not want to be taking a picture of the bride's veil going by and not the bride, you want to make sure that the camera has a low shutter lag. They also can take up to 15 seconds in-between pictures. Then there is the connection methods and card formats to worry about. Many cameras come with unique cables to tie in to your computer. Some have standard USB, which is much better if you lose/damage a cable. Then you have to worry about the card format - some formats dissappear - leaving you holding the bag trying to get new cards when you want more storage. MMC, Compact Flash, Digital Film, Secure Digital (SD) & Memory Stick are all completely different storage formats. Do you know they sell 16-in-one digital card readers to plug into your computer? This is an attempt to offer a place to plug in all the differnt cards you might have to deal with. You should research which cards are popular when you are going to buy and go with that - and get a large one - you want to be able to store a lot of pictures. Also there is the issue of the screen size - with a digital, you may be using the preview screen quite a bit - is it 1.5", 2.5" backlit (to show up in sunlight), can I shut it off to save batteries? LCD or OLED (for brighter viewing). Even the resolution can be different - just like a computer monitor. And batteries - some are hogs. Some use regular camera batteries, some use cheap rechargeables, good rechargeables, standard batteries too - find one that suits your demands. And then there is digital zoom. Offered in almost every camera, you should shut this feature off as soon as you can (if you can). It does nothing but "blow up" an area of the photo already limited by how many megapixels the camera has. It does nothing but degrade the original entire photo and throw away information. With digital, part of the promise in enlarging, so why would you bother doing it in the camera and throwing away part of the image.

BUYING TOO SOON - Digital photography is only 11 years old. Apple Computer introduced the first consumer digital camera in 1994. Hard to believe huh? This is not a stable industry. There is innovation every day, and products drop in price every year. A 6 Megapixel that was $5,000 2 years ago is $500 this year, and will be 9 Megapixel a year or two with better sensors, options, etc, and probably $300. Early adopters pay a premium for technology, and are often disappointed in how quickly they have to "catch up" the the late arrivers.

ARCHIVING - Digital files and photographs in particular have no means of being archived and stored over a long period of time. Let me put that in perspective. What is the oldest digital file you currently have? I can't think of any that I have over 10 years old. My earliest Mac was purchased 1988 - forget about the computers before then, and I am almost certain I have none of the material I originally had on that machine. I can tell you I had lists of books in a database program that is no longer valid, so I think I threw it away or imported it into something else. I know I have some floppies in a box somewhere - 90% chance they are no good any longer. All media decays - Hard Drives crash, Disks go bad, CDs deteriorate and get scratched - so there is no tangible archiving of photos like the negatives in film photography. I understand that there are archival-quality CDs and DVDs being produced - some promise lasting up to 100 years, but they are unproven, and hard to find. Even the memory cards themselves get corrupt. Did you know that the Mars explorer robots got bogged down because of corrupt Flash Memory cards - they had to reformat them remotely from Earth. Every picture stored digitally is in a kind of limbo, waiting for the device or media it is on to destruct.
Now, how old are the oldest photos that you have? I have some over 100 years old, and they look pretty good, and I want to be able pass them on to my children - I wonder if that will happen with digital.

FORMAT - what about format of the files? JPEG files have been around for a while, but will they last 100 years? There is almost no file format over 15 years old that is in popular use today. The Library of Congress is even concerned about this. They have most of their photos stored as TIFF files - not even a highly popular format any more, except for professionals, but it has benefits. TIFF files can be left uncompressed. JPEG is a LOSSY compression format. When you save something as JPG, you will lose some detail - even on the highest quality setting. Better not to compress at all if possible - but the problem is that the files will then be big. Some cameras allow you to save to RAW format - the data that is captured by the camera itself - but there is little in the way of standards - some cameras record RAW differently than others. Read this quote from the Library of Congress website... "Digital materials are surprisingly fragile. They depend for their continued viability upon technologies that undergo rapid and continual change. All digital materials require rendering software to be useful, and they are generally created in formats specific to a given rendering environment. In the world of paper, many valuable research resources have been saved passively; acquired by individuals or organizations, stored in little-visited recesses, and still viable decades later. That will not happen with the digital equivalents. Changes in computing technology will ensure that over relatively short periods of time, both the media and the technical format of old digital materials will become unusable. Keeping digital resources for use by future generations will require conscious effort and continual investment".

You may say who cares about format, but let me give you a film example - I have been using the APS format, and the developer that I was going to (Ritz Camera) said they would no longer be buying the ribbons to print the dates on the back of my photos (which I like), because APS was falling out of favor. That they eventually will not even have APS film or albums or on-site developing. Format is very important in the long run. Ever hear of Photo-Disks or 110 Film? You don't want to be made obsolete.

PRINTOUTS - The printouts that most people do at home from digital cameras are not going to last that long. Epson gets the highest marks for longevity with its Stylus Photo prints which should remain fade-free for 100-plus years when using Pigmented Archival Inks and high-end papers. That's decades longer than even traditional prints can claim (prints on Fuji's Crystal Archive paper last for 60 years, and those on Kodak's Ektacolor Edge 8 fade after 22 years). But at around $600, these printers are very expensive, as is the ink. Other printers and paper combinations last even less, but the consumables are cheaper. Canon and Epson also offer models that deliver an average of 26 years of print life in tests, but look for archival inks (usually with pigment), and
However, Epson has had problems with the 870 and its $399 wide-format 1270 sibling. The printers debuted last year boasting high quality and long print life, but users found that heavy ozone concentrations reacted with some prints, turning them orange quickly (sometimes in days).

Epson recently had a bit of a flap because prints from it's "archival quality" printer ($600) were fading after only a couple years. This is because the inks used in a printer fade in time, by the effects of light and air, even if they are very expensive printer inks. It even matters which paper you print on. Photos 100 years old can be reshot and used to make reprints - it's doubtful anything coming off your printer at home will be able to do the same in 20 years. Most people have no idea what they are spending per print - but there are some interesting statistics out there. The name-brand ink for many printers sells for over $3,000 per gallon. That is not a typo. That is how much ink you are getting in those tiny little cartridges they charge $20-30 for. Color lasers are coming down in price (some down to $300), but laser lacks the quality of other photo-printing methods. Then there is the paper - very expensive. Consumer Reports recently calculated that people printing at home are spending approximately $0.45 per print (almost $11 for 24) and I don't think that includes the cost of waste - misprints and such (which we all get). So, good printers with archival quality inks are highly expensive to own and operate and have few benefits over traditional film developing.

DISPLAYING - Most people I know with digital pictures no longer have photo albums. They no longer have pictures visible of any sort that are easily accessible. They are often locked away in their computers or on a storage card. They mean to print them - they just often do not. I know people who actually miss their old film cameras. If you go digital, you have to be willing to produce the pictures you come up with. The promise of things like displaying them on a TV is often not met, or used very infrequently.

SIMPLICITY - With all these things to worry about, film starts to sound really good. Load, take picture, develop - store the prints and the negatives. But, there are some really compelling reasons to want to go digital, but I don't think the promise has been fulfilled as much as people believe. There are millions of people now taking pictures with their cheap digitals that are inferior, and will most likely be lost over the course of years. They will be denying their children the pictoral history that they were most likely handed.

I myself take a diffent approach. Since I use APS, I can scan an entire roll of film into my computer in one step. So I take pics, develop, get double-prints (for giving away), scan the roll digitally, and archive the negatives. I then have many of the digital benefits, and none of the loss in archivability. Another option is to get a CD made digitally at the time you develop. At $3-$4 per disc, it may still be cheaper to develop and get a CD than print digitally at home. But, I admit that digital holds an allure, and I will go over those in Part II - The Promise - http://trekbody.blogspot.com/2005/09/digital-photo-guide-part-2-promise.html.